I recently had the pleasure of taking TCM Security's Practical Network Penetration Tester (PNPT) exam. Since PNPT is the new kid on the block, change is scary, and a relatively small number of folks have had the opportunity to take (let alone complete) PNPT, I wanted to make my thoughts available for interested parties.
Full-Disclosure: I am a participant in the TCM Academy Partner Program . I will receive a 25% commission from sales generated using the affiliate links in this post.
For the sake of transparency, I want to share my background going into the exam. I have a B.S. in Computer Information Systems. My degree incorporated a double-concentration in Systems Development and Information Assurance and Security. I also hold an upper-division undergraduate certificate in Applied Cybersecurity from the SANS Institute. The red team certifications that I've completed prior to PNPT are Pentest+, eJPT, and GPEN. Professionally, I've been a software developer for just under two years, most recently at a full-spectrum cybersecurity company.
I consider myself to be an early-career software developer, as that's what pays my bills. That aside, I am an offensive security enthusiast. As it's related to information technology, if I'm not studying and practicing software development, I'm sharpening my red team skills.
Edit 8/10/2022: I am currently employed at TCM Security as a Senior Security Engineer. I began working here in April of 2022. I completed the PNPT exam in December of 2021, prior to beginning my work on the new exam platform.
Why Take PNPT?
I opted to take PNPT for a few reasons:
- The exam is 100% practical--I've never personally been on a penetration test and wanted to gain hands-on experience in the event that I ever am asked to cover down on an engagement.
- PNPT is rapidly appearing on job listings.
- I'm a fan of TCM Security's mission of making education affordable and wanted to support them.
- It's affordable. Especially compared to most certifications available in the industry.
Preparing for the PNPT
Per the recommendations of TCM Security, I prepared for the exam by completing the following courses:
I had taken Practical Ethical Hacking (PEH) originally on Udemy roughly a year ago. Since then, Heath Adams (CEO of TCM Security) revamped the mid-course capstone and updated much of the course material. As a result, I opted to refresh myself on the new course material.
Edit 8/10/2022: Since I took the PNPT, the preparation roadmap for the exam has been updated to include the Windows Privilege Escalation for Beginners and Linux Privilege Escalation for Beginners courses. See the infographic below.
The Exam Experience
All PNPT candidates are obligated to keep information about the exam confidential. As such, I'm unable to discuss specifics outside of what is publicly available on TCM Security's website.
That aside, I found the experience notable compared to other industry standard exams. Students are provided an individual (read: non-shared) network environment. They are given five days to complete a penetration test within the scope defined in the rules of engagement. The goal is to 1) compromise the domain controller (DC) 2) achieve persistent access to the DC.
The student is allotted 5 days in the environment, with an additional 2 days to complete a professional penetration test report. If the student does not achieve domain admin, they can submit a report with their progress and receive a hint for their retake. Once the DC is compromised and the report is submitted and approved, the student then has to debrief a panel of senior penetration testers from TCM Security on their methodology and findings. Students who satisfactorily complete all of these requirements are awarded the PNPT certification.
Aspects of the exam that stood out to me:
- It is definitively a penetration test in a simulated environment based off of real-world penetration tests. There are no multiple choice and it is not a CTF.
- Support was responsive and helpful. The environment could be reset quickly as needed, per the student's request.
- There was no proctor requirement.
- All tools, techniques, and procedures were fair game. The only limitation was that the student was expected to complete the exam without outside assistance.
- At the time of this writing, and GPEN aside, this is the only junior level penetration tester certification exam that I've taken that included Active Directory components.
- I never once experienced any service interruptions with the exam environment.
In sum, it does exactly what it says on the can.
The Retake Policy
TCM Security's retake policy is particularly interesting. TCM Security offers a free retake with a voucher. For the sake of complete transparency, I failed PNPT on my first attempt. Per the retake policy, I was able to submit a report with my current progress in exchange for a nudge and a second attempt.
Herein lies my only gripe with the PNPT experience--the nudge I was given did not matter as my retake environment was different from my original environment.
Unfortunately, this is somewhat unavoidable as folks have attempted to grift off of the no-proctor policy and sell exam secrets. This has required TCM Security to abandon compromised environments. As such, it's unlikely a student will see the same environment on a retake.
The report is an oft dreaded component of penetration tests, but I didn't find it too cumbersome. I attribute this mainly to the advice given by Tim Medin in SEC560 at SANS--work on your report while you're testing. On my second attempt, I knocked over the DC by day three and was able to finish my report before the time in the environment would have expired. This was due in no small part to my note taking and screenshotting throughout the exam.
PEH does a good job of outlining the expectations of a professional penetration test report and Heath makes a template available in a repository on his Github . I highly recommend taking advantage of these resources.
There's also an External Penetration Test checklist available on Heath's GitHub. I found it helpful during my initial approach of the environment.
For the debrief, I spoke with Heath directly. He asked me to walk him through the attack chain and explain the recommended mitigations. The entire process took about ten minutes, and he immediately released the certificate to me at the end of the call.
In conclusion, I recommend PNPT. Of all of the other entry level penetration testing certifications out there, this is the only one that requires you to complete a penetration test, write a report, and present your findings--just like in a real penetration test.
Beyond that, the price is unbeatable. The standalone exam is $299, while the bundle with training is $399. The only more affordable option is the eLearnSecurity eJPT--$200 for the voucher and free training with the INE Starter Pass (and includes a free retake). The next most affordable option is CompTIA PenTest+ at $349 without training--and the exam is little more than hacker trivia.
The one major drawback to PNPT is that it is new. Because of this, the current job listings are sparse (7 listings on LinkedIn as of the time of this writing). That said, the fact that it has any listings at all within the year of its debut is rather promising (consider that eJPT only has 11 listings and it has been around for years). As it gains a foothold in the industry, I would expect to see the recognition and demand grow.
Edited 12/28/2021: This post originally stated that TCM Academy was the only education company in the industry to provide a free retake with an exam voucher. This is incorrect. eLearnSecurity also provides a free retake with the eJPT voucher.